How it works

How a session works

Each session takes on one question of public life over about two hours. A short framing gives everyone shared ground, and after that the floor belongs to the people in the room.

An illustration of a hall with chairs set out in a horseshoe facing a screen, and no lectern.
The format

A forum, not a lecture

I open each session with a framing of no more than fifteen minutes: a few terms, a few facts, and the question we are there to argue about. It exists so that people who arrive without any background can take part on equal terms.

After that I convene. I keep the queue of speakers and step in if the conversation needs steering, which is the job rather than a criticism of anyone. The conclusions are yours to draw, not mine.

The chairs are set out in a horseshoe, with no lectern and no top table, so that everyone in the room can see everyone else.

What the forum is not

No house position. Nothing to sell.

The forum takes no collective position on the questions it discusses. It is self-funded, and there is no product, party, or campaign behind it.

The briefs document the range of arguments made in the room. They do not claim that the room agreed, and where it disagreed, they say so.

The one rule

The Chatham House Rule

You may repeat and quote what you hear. You may not say who said it.

How the room works

The four norms

  1. Listen before you respond
  2. Make room for other voices
  3. Disagree with the idea, not the person
  4. This is not a debate

Disagreement is welcome; dominance is not. If you tend to speak a lot, practise holding back. If you tend to hold back, this is a room where your voice is wanted.

“This is not a debate” does not mean that we avoid argument. A debate has sides and a winner; here there is neither, and the aim of an argument is to understand the strongest version of a view you do not hold, rather than to defeat it.

Taking part

Two ways to take part

Speak

Raise a hand and I add you to the queue. The queue is there so that the quickest voice in the room is not the only one heard.

Write

Post on the live board from your phone, under any display name you choose, and upvote, react to, or reply to other posts. Posts that break the norms are hidden.

Both count equally in the brief.

On foot

The walking discussion

Partway through a session, the room breaks into small groups that take the question outside and argue it on foot, a habit the forum inherits from Walk & Talk. Each group then reports back to the whole room. If it rains, we find somewhere covered.

Afterwards

A brief that travels

After each session I write a policy brief: a record of what was argued, with nobody named, which keeps what participants said apart from what I, as convenor, draw from it.

The draft goes first to everyone who attended, who can correct it and comment on it. The final brief then goes to the officials, elected members, and organisations whose work the question touches, and it is published on this site.

Questions

Before your first session

What is Hear Me Out: The Civic Room?

It is a facilitated civic forum in Auckland, which I convene as a programme of Walk & Talk Auckland. Each session takes on one question of public life over about two hours, and what was argued is written up as a policy brief for decision-makers.

Do I need to know about the topic before I come?

You do not need any background, because each session opens with a framing of no more than fifteen minutes: a few terms, a few facts, and the question. It exists so that people who arrive without any background can take part on equal terms.

How do I reserve a seat?

Sessions are listed first on the Walk & Talk Auckland Meetup group, which is where you reserve a seat. The number of seats is set by the size of the room, so the Meetup listing is the place to watch.

Will what I say be attributed to me?

Every session runs under the Chatham House Rule: you may repeat and quote what you hear, but you may not say who said it. The policy brief records the arguments made in the room without naming anyone, and nothing on this site names anyone who took part. At the end of a session I usually suggest a group photograph, but joining it is entirely voluntary, and if you would rather not appear in it, that choice is respected. Whether or not you are in the photograph, nothing you said is attributed to you.

Is a session a debate?

A session is not a debate, although argument is welcome. A debate has sides and a winner; here there is neither, and the aim of an argument is to understand the strongest version of a view you do not hold, rather than to defeat it.

What if I would rather not speak aloud?

You can post on the live board from your phone, under any display name you choose, and upvote, react to, or reply to other posts. What you write counts in the brief equally with what is said aloud.

Does the forum take a political position?

The forum takes no collective position on the questions it discusses. It is self-funded, and there is no product, party, or campaign behind it.

What happens after a session?

I write a policy brief that records what was argued. The draft goes first to everyone who attended, who can correct it and comment on it, and the final brief then goes to the officials, elected members, and organisations whose work the question touches, and is published on this site.